Tag Archives: GDP growth

Latest China GDP Figures Show Stable But Challenged Growth

Screen Shot 2018-10-20 at 10.44.23 AM

IF THERE IS a scintilla of concern for authorities in the third-quarter GDP growth figure, covering July-September, it is that the tariffs imposed by the United States have not had much time to have a material impact.

At 6.5% year-on-year, the third-quarter number represents the slowest quarterly growth rate since the first quarter of 2009 in the immediate aftermath of the 2008 global financial crisis. However, it is still in line with the official growth target for the year. For the first nine months, GDP grew at an above-target 6.7%, according to the National Bureau of Statistics, which generally portrays the economy as “running within reasonable range in the first three quarters, and [continuing] to stay stable with good growing momentum”.

However, as the economists like to say, all the risks are on the downside: Trump’s tariffs; the ticking debt time bomb; and the pains of rebalancing.

In particular, with the Trump administration ramping up its tariffs in the current quarter and no resolution to the trade frictions between the two countries in sight, further policy support for the economy is going to be needed. However, policymakers’ scope to stimulate the economy is limited by high debt levels, in part taken on to finance the infrastructure investment boom that was the stimulative response to the 2008 financial crisis.

Giving banks more freedom to grow their loan books, trusting their credit judgements are better — or less politically swayed — than they have been in the past, will be preferred to increasing direct government spending. There will some of that, though, too, if growth is seen as slowing uncomfortably fast once the current round of US tariffs takes effect, or is followed by another.

Investors are less than convinced. Hence the raft of bullish statements from President Xi Jinping’s top economic adviser and the heads of the securities regulator, the combined insurance and banking watchdog and the central bank urging investors to stay calm as the main stock market index neared a four-year low.

However, the important words are yet to be spoken. Those will exchanged between Presidents Xi and Donald Trump when they meet at the G20 leaders’ summit in Buenos Aires at the end of November and may give an indication of which direction the trade disputes between the two countries are headed in.

Advertisements

Leave a comment

Filed under Economy, Uncategorized

Trade Tension And A Less Certain Outlook Cloud China’s Economy

THE INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND has held its growth projections for China unchanged even as it warned of growing downside risks to the global outlook.

The newly published July update to its World Economic Outlook puts its forecast GDP growth at 6.6% for this year and 6.4% for next. It cites softening world demand and regulatory and financial tightening as the reasons why.

The Fund’s forecast is in line with official figures for the second quarter released today by the the National Bureau of Statistics showing the economy growing by 6.7% year-on-year in the second quarter, the twelfth consecutive quarter of 6.7-6.9% growth.

Rebalancing, evidenced by private and public consumption contributing a record 78.5% of January-June GDP growth, continues as does excess-capacity reduction; mining sector output grew by at less than a quarter of the pace of overall industrial output.

Net export volumes shaved 0.7 of a percentage point off first-half growth as exporters and importers raced to beat the imposition of US tariffs. The effect of those are likely to be felt more severely in the second half of this year.

For its part, the IMF notes:

The recently announced and anticipated tariff increases by the United States and retaliatory measures by trading partners have increased the likelihood of escalating and sustained trade actions. These could derail the recovery and depress medium-term growth prospects, both through their direct impact on resource allocation and productivity and by raising uncertainty and taking a toll on investment.

To trade tensions, the Fund adds rising US interest rates and commodity prices, notably oil, as among the most concerning downside risks to the global economy.

The Fund’s prescription that ‘avoiding protectionist measures and finding a cooperative solution that promotes continued growth in goods and services trade remain essential to preserve the global expansion’ may find more resonance in Beijing that Washington these days, as will its call to preserve global economic integration under an open, rules-based multilateral trade system.

Leave a comment

Filed under Economy

Powering Up Rebalancing

Bar chart of electric power consumption in China by sector, Jan-May, 2018, year-on-year % increase.

ELECTRIC POWER CONSUMPTION acts as a proxy for economic activity. These sectoral figures from the National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC) for the first five months of this year give a snapshot of where the growth is strongest, and points up how the economy is rebalancing.

Leave a comment

Filed under Economy

IMF Sees China’s Economy With Momentum To Face Headwinds

IN ITS LATEST World Economic Outlook, the International Monetary Fund has left its forecast for China’s growth this year and next unchanged from January’s 6.6% and 6.4% respectively.

Both numbers are one-tenth of a percentage point higher than the Fund’s forecast in October last year. They are also in line with the most recent forecasts from the World Bank and the OECD.

Faster than expected global growth and domestic policy support has sustained the economy in the form of resurgent net exports and healthy private consumption, giving it some momentum to propel it into the challenging headwinds of America First protectionism and still-risky domestic overleverage.

Thereafter, the IMF provides a familiar refrain:

Over the medium term, the economy is projected to continue rebalancing away from investment toward private consumption and from industry to services, but nonfinancial debt is expected to continue rising as a share of GDP, and the accumulation of vulnerabilities clouds the medium-term outlook.

And its obligatory silver lining:

Tighter regulation of nonbank intermediation in China, where nonfinancial corporate sector debt is still rising, is a welcome start of a needed policy response to contain the accumulation of vulnerabilities.

But it also highlights a missed opportunity:

Fiscal policy has played a vital part in shoring up short-term growth at the expense of eroding valuable policy space. Gradual consolidation, together with a shift of spending back onto the budget and away from off-budget channels, would help improve sustainability.

The Fund’s accompanying Global Financial Stability Report goes into greater depth about the elevated risks posed by what it says is the large-scale, tight and opaque linking of the banking system to the shadow banking sector (see diagram below) through its exposure to off-balance-sheet investment vehicles largely funded through the issuance of some 75 trillion yuan ($12 trillion) of investment products.

One-third of those by value are directly managed by the banks, who are seen as implicitly guaranteeing the products. A key challenge for authorities will be phasing out those implicit guarantees, which will require banks to improve their liquidity and capital buffers as there are large maturity mismatches between the products’ assets and liabilities.

Diagram of linkages within China's financial system. Credit: IMF Global Stability Report, April 2018

Leave a comment

Filed under Economy

OECD Raises China Growth Forecast And Risks To It

THE OECD HAS edged up its growth forecast for China this year to 6.7% from the 6.6% it projected in November but holds its 2019 forecast unchanged at 6.4%. The revised numbers are contained in the newly published interim Economic Outlook from the rich countries’ think tank.

Overall, the OECD sees a steady or improving expansion across most G20 economies thanks to the bounce back of trade and private investment, with fiscal stimulus in the United States and Germany providing a boost to short-term growth, while inflationary pressures are subdued. Specifically, on China it says

Growth surprised on the upside in China in 2017, helped by a strong rebound in exports, but is set to soften to just below 6½ per cent by 2019. Macroeconomic and regulatory policies are gradually becoming more restrictive, the working age population is now declining and credit conditions are less expansionary. Regulatory efforts are continuing to reduce financial risks, deal with overcapacity in some sectors and improve environmental quality. Fiscal policy is now broadly neutral, but additional measures could be implemented if output growth were to slow more sharply.

However, the risks to its general forecast all threaten particular vulnerabilities of the Chinese economy: tightening monetary policy in the advanced economies, high debt and asset valuations, and a potentially damaging escalation of trade tensions.

The importance of tackling high debt levels is illustrated in this chart.

Chart of G20 total debt, public and private non-financial sector, as % of GDP, 2001-2017. Source: OECD

The OECD calls on Beijing for policy initiatives to reduce the high level of corporate debt, in particular.

The OECD also makes a point of the importance of safeguarding the rules-based international trading system. China has repeatedly been saying the same thing, if somewhat self-servingly and with itself as the guarantor, since long before the Trump administration announced import tariffs on steel and aluminium. It is likely to echo the call again as the United States readies a Section 301 action on intellectual property rights and technology transfer practices aimed at what the US president has flatly called China’s theft of US technology.

Meanwhile, the Trump administration has reportedly told Beijing that it has to come up with a plan to reduce China’s $375 billion trade surplus with the United States by $100 billion within a year.

2 Comments

Filed under China-U.S., Economy, Trade

Steady GDP Growth Target Reflects Measured Derisking

Chinese Premier Li Keqiang delivers his work report at the first session of the 13th National People's Congress in the Great Hall of the People in Beijing, March 5, 2018. Photo credit: Xinhua.

THE OFFICIAL GDP growth target for 2018 is ‘around 6.5%’, the same as last year, when the outcome was a forecast 6.9%, Prime Minister Li Keqiang (above) told the National Peoples Congress in his annual work report. However, the aspirational text from last year on the upside of the target has been dropped for this.

More significantly, the deficit target has been cut for the first time since 2012, to 2.6% of GDP from 3.0%, and monetary policy is to remain neutral, suggesting a tightening of the fiscal screw as authorities’ preferred way to de-risk the financial system.

If the 6.5% growth target is hit, China will be comfortably on course to achieve the goal set in 2010 of doubling per capita GDP by 2020 and thus making it a ‘moderately well-off society’. Growth needs to average only 6.3% between 2018 and 2020 for the target to be achieved.

Less certain is the extent to which quality of growth will replace quantity, as advertised at October’s quinquennial Party Congress. Li repeated the intention to reduce debt-fuelled investment, pollution, poverty and industrial overcapacity, in line with the Party line, but a 6.5% growth target would imply more economic stimulus or less fiscal drag than might otherwise be expected under the managed long-term slowdown and rebalancing of the economy.

That continues incrementally. He Lifeng, head of the National Development and Reform Commission, said on the sidelines of the NPC that consumption is likely to contribute around 60% to economic growth in 2018, up from 58.8% last year and barely 56% five years ago.

He also identified plate glass, cement and electrolytic aluminium as among the next round of target industries for capacity cuts.

The new GDP growth target also implies that the pace of structural financial reform will remain cautious, as it has been for some time. Deleveraging via cracking down on corporations, as happened to Anbang and more recently CEFC China Energy, will continue to be a way of removing excess financial risk from the system while serving the twin goal of aligning private sector foreign direct investment with the national interest.

Similarly, on the debt issue, Finance Minister Xiao Jie indicates that administrative action will be taken against irregularities in local government financing. Local governments account for 55% of the combined debt of central and local governments of  29.95 trillion yuan ($4.75 trillion) at the end of last year.

While some progress has been made on both reducing local government debt levels and structural reforms to local government financing, local governments remain overly dependent on land sales, with the concomitant risk of abuse.

However, a trade war, depending on its severity and duration, might make all that moot.

Leave a comment

Filed under Economy

China’s Economy: Normal Slowing Will Resume in 2018

THE ECONOMY STORMED along in the second half of last year, taking growth for the year to 6.9%, comfortably outstripping the official target of ‘around 6.5%’.

It was riding the coattails of the fiscal stimulus introduced in the first half of the year and also the pick-up in global trade, partly helped by the robust growth in the United States and some recovery in Europe, which boosted China’s exports. At 8.7% of China’s GDP growth, net export volumes made their largest contribution to growth since 2008.

Policymakers have been managing a slowdown from the giddy decades of double-digit growth. The overall lesson from last week’s figures is that economy is fitfully rebalancing and that there was some slowdown in credit growth as official efforts to cool the property market, deleverage and upgrade industrial capacity gained some traction.

That last year turned out to be the first acceleration since 2010 should prove to be an anomaly. Normal slowing will resume this year. And especially if policymakers push ahead with measures to control financial risks.

The most recent forecast from the World Bank, which recently upped its estimate of GDP growth in 2017 to 6.8% (a 0.3 percentage point increase from its forecast a year ago and reiterated in June) says it expects 6.4% growth this year (a 0.1 percentage point increase from its previous number).

Beijing has plenty of headroom in meeting its 2010 target of doubling aggregate and per capita growth by 2020. The economy needs to average no more than 6.3% growth to achieve that.

That headroom will also let Beijing tackle its most pressing economic-related problems: curbing escalating debt; cutting excess heavy industrial capacity; becoming environmentally cleaner; and dealing with the risk of unemployment as the economy is rebalanced towards domestic consumption and higher-value-added manufacturing.

Where the margins of safety are considerably thinner is if there is a trade war with the United States.

As we noted recently, US President Donald Trump is itching to impose tariffs on Chinese steel and aluminium imports into the United States. More recently Washington has said that an investigation into intellectual property transfers to China has been launched, with Trump warning that China is in for “a very big intellectual property fine”.

His self-restraint because he needs Beijing’s help with North Korea is wearing thin. Nor will it have been helped by the revelation that an ex-CIA officer arrested in New York this week may have been the mole responsible for passing information to Chinese intelligence that led to the dismantling and death of the CIA’s intelligence network in China between 2010 and 2012.

Leave a comment

Filed under China-U.S., Economy, Trade